Why Your Oven Air Fry Isn't Crispy (And How to Fix It)

December 27, 2025

Have you ever planned on crispy air-fried fries or wings—only to pull out food that’s… kind of soft? If you’re using your oven’s Air Fry setting, you’re not alone. Oven air fry can absolutely work, but it’s more sensitive to airflow, spacing, and setup than most people realize.

The real problem: airflow

Countertop air fryers are basically small, high-powered convection ovens with tight airflow. Your oven is much larger, so the hot air has more space to move—and if your food is blocking circulation (or sitting on a solid pan), moisture gets trapped and crispiness drops.

The goal is simple:

keep hot air moving around the food from as many sides as possible.

https://dailycook7.com/products/b0d2d21fkm

5 Easy Fixes for Crispier Oven Air Fry Results

1) Preheat (seriously—don’t skip it)

Oven air fry works best when the heat and airflow are already strong when the food goes in.
Try: 3–5 minutes of preheat on Air Fry/Convection.

2) Don’t overcrowd the pan

If pieces are touching or stacked, you’re basically steaming them.
Try: Cook in a single layer. If you have a lot, do two batches—it’s worth it.

3) Use the right surface (this matters more than people think)

A flat sheet pan blocks airflow underneath, so the bottom stays softer.
Try: A raised rack or a mesh-style oven air fry basket with a drip tray can help air circulate under the food and let grease drip away instead of pooling.

(If you want a reference example, the Amazon link you shared is the “mesh basket + tray” style I mean—use any similar setup that fits your oven.)

4) Light oil = better crisp (too much oil = soggy)

You don’t need a lot—just enough to help browning and surface crisp.
Try: A quick spray or a very light toss. Oils with higher smoke points (like avocado or grapeseed) work well.

5) Flip once, then leave it alone

Constant flipping drops heat and slows browning.
Try: Flip or shake once halfway through for fries/nuggets/veg, then let it finish.

Optional “Pro Move”: A quick broil at the end

If everything is cooked through but you want extra crunch, a short broil can help.
Try: 30–90 seconds under the broiler—watch closely so it doesn’t burn.